Oregon to Garnish Execs Pay if They Don’t Shut Down Coal Plant


An Oregon voters’ ballot initiative would garnish the wages of power company executives who won’t shut down coal power stations in the state.

A ballot initiative, from the environmental group Renew Oregon aims to shut down coal-fired power in the state. It has already gathered twice as many signatures as it needed to be certified; the first step.

With four thousand signatures, Renew Oregon has qualified a pair of ballot initiatives designed to eliminate coal-fired electricity entirely from Oregon by 2030.

One of the ballot initiatives requires coal-fired power stations to cease operation by 2030. So that the power generation doesn’t pass from highly polluting coal power to natural gas with its own increasingly troubling emissions from fracking operations, this measure also requires that at least half of all new generation must come from renewable sources.

A precedent-setting legal penalty – executive wages garnished

The second ballot measure backs this up with a pretty wild penalty. It would actually have the state garnish the wages of executives of any companies that refused to comply the law.

This ballot measure is a well-written legal document – and must surely be setting a precedent as the first time ever that voters have actually threatened harm to the executives of firms for the actions that they take. Even state level Renewable Energy Standards (RES) include financial penalties and fines only for the utility itself, if it fails to meet them.


(1) To the extent allowed by law, notwithstanding the cost limitation provided for by ORS 469A.100, in any year in which an electric company does not meet the standards set forth in ORS 469A.052(1), the chief executive officer and the chief financial officer (or persons holding the equivalent positions) of that electric company may not receive any form of compensation (including, but not limited to, salary, bonuses, stock options, dividends, distributions, benefits or other remuneration or income) from the electric company or any entity affiliated with the electric company that exceeds five times the annual Oregon median household income in the preceding year. For the purposes of this section, the Oregon median household income shall be the Oregon median household income as determined by the United States Census Bureau American Community Survey.”

Renew Oregon’s aim is to shut down coal-fired power from Oregon’s energy mix and double the amount of renewable energy used in the state by 2030

The environmental organization has passed the first step by getting 4,000 signatures to Oregon’s Secretary of State Office for certification.

Now, once the initiatives are certified, the group will then need to collect more than 88,000 signatures for each title in order to get them onto Oregon’s ballot for November 2016.

Coal accounts for about 33% of Oregon’s power currently while under 10% is supplied by solar and wind

Oregon does get quite a high percentage of its power from coal – about a third. Many US states are closer to or above 20% renewable now, and the state has lagged in building renewables. However, it does have a very high percentage of hydropower, and if it could eliminate coal and double its solar and wind, together with the hydro, Oregon’s energy supply would be a 90% clean.

Image Credit: fancycrave1 via Pixabay under Creative Commons Licence

Susan Kraemer

Susan Kraemer writes at Earthtechling, Renewable Energy World, CleanTechnica and CSP-Today. She has also been published at Wind Energy Update, PV-Insider, GreenProphet, Ecoseed, NRDC OnEarth and Scientific American.As a former serial entrepreneur in product design, Susan brings an innovator's perspective on inventing a carbon-constrained civilization: If necessity is the mother of invention, solving climate change is the mother of all necessities! As a lover of history and sci-fi, she enjoys chronicling the strange future we are creating in these interesting times. Follow Susan on Twitter @dotcommodity.

    • Ian

      The provision that at least 50% of all new generation to be from renewables seems kind of weak to me. Preliminary figures show that about 75% of all new generating capacity in the US this year will be renewables.