Solar Power And What Could Be Its Biggest Obstacles

The sun has long been seen as one of the most promising power sources of the future. Plentiful, clean and free, solar energy tantalizes with the promise of solving the global energy crisis and alleviating climate change.

For a while, the world seemed to be on board with this vision. In 2008, venture capitalists backed hundreds of solar energy startups. The money flowed, and with it came ideas and innovations aimed at fast-tracking renewable energy on national and even global scales.

Then clouds — political, economic, social — began to cast shadows on the once-promising industry. Increased efforts to tap into the massive oil sands reserves beneath Alberta’s boreal forests lent the impression that North America was on the verge of energy independence, lessening the perceived need to develop renewable technologies. Then China entered the photovoltaic panel market, revolutionizing solar energy with amazingly low prices and forcing a number of companies that could not compete out of business. The cheap prices drove investors away and made it seem like solar no longer needed financial support, even though renewable energy in the U.S. was only in its infancy.

“It would be better to sell popcorn right now — there’s more money in that.” – Herb HaydenThe global recession dealt the final blow, turning focus toward cheap energy and quick solutions and distracting from long-term investments and thinking. As political and social interest in solar declined along with the economy, funding likewise dried up. Droves of once-promising startups and solar ventures, including those managed by major companies such as BP, Bosch and Sharp, declared bankruptcy. Others underwent major restructuring and hunkered down their efforts, just trying to survive. The solar energy bubble had burst.

“It would be better to sell popcorn right now — there’s more money in that,” says Herb Hayden, president and chief technical officer of Southwest Solar Technology LLC in Arizona, one of the companies that chose to restructure rather than give up. “I’m serious when I talk about how horrible it is. It’s just a thankless activity now.”

Political “Won’t”

In the new landscape of solar energy, several factors continue to confound recovery efforts. The lingering scars of the recession are no small obstacle. In the U.S., the average cost of electricity is 10 cents per kilowatt-hour, whereas solar costs around 30 to 50 cents for that same amount of power. Some European governments in similar circumstances get around this problem by aggressively subsidizing production of solar-powered electricity with taxpayer money. In the U.S., on the other hand, solar must compete with cheap, largely subsidized natural gas.

image via Shutterstock

image via Shutterstock

“That is why Germany, which has about one-fourth the population of the United States, has a total amount of solar power about six times higher than us,” says Martin Hoffert, a professor emeritus of physics at New York University.

While Germany’s government may see the need for aggressively pushing forward with a renewable energy agenda, U.S. politicians are not the best prepared for engineering and science decision making. Out of the 541 seats in the U.S. Congress, fewer than a dozen are held by scientists or engineers. Lacking technical expertise, U.S. politicians can struggle to discern the best source of information about renewable energy. Conventional energy suppliers try to convince them that newfangled solar technologies will not be a success, while scientists assure them that solar is the way to go. In between are the public, advisors and various interest groups, all pulling in different directions.

Though lack of political will may stand as solar’s biggest obstacle, the technology, too, has a ways to go if it’s going to be implemented on a much larger scale.“I think the biggest obstacle are politicians,” says David Faiman, a professor emeritus of engineering and physics at Ben-Gurion University of the Negev in Israel. “Specifically, I think they’re probably nervous about making very large changes and are also under considerable pressure from current power suppliers not to make those large changes.”

Will Work for Innovations

Though lack of political will may stand as solar’s biggest obstacle, the technology, too, has a ways to go if it’s going to be implemented on a much larger scale.

The labs and start-ups that have managed to survive are striving to get various solar-energy-capturing options up to par, particularly in scalability and pricing. In Arizona, for example, Hayden is building high-performance photovoltaic cells that require less capital and less risk investment than other companies, many of which have gone or are going out of business. Unlike other venues, Southwest Solar Technologies will build a key part of the system but also incorporate equipment made by other groups. This will lend Hayden’s product versatility and robustness, he thinks, that others who custom design their entire technologies lack. Still, even with these cost-saving strategies, in order for Hayden and others to survive they will need some resources.

“It’s not a slam dunk,” he says. “As we work on attacking the problems, we also have to come up with less risky ways of introducing the technology in order to be more attractive to potential partners.”

Storage is another issue. One of the biggest impediments to solar is its dependence on the sun’s unbroken glare. Ideally, solar energy could be captured while the sun brightly shines and then stored for later use after sunset or when clouds roll in, but current power storage capabilities are not up to task for storing the massive amounts of energy widespread deployment would bring. Researchers are working on storage technologies, but again, such efforts need funding to reach their goal.

Transmission is another challenge. Most of the world’s power grid relies upon alternating current, but this form of electric power delivery is not well suited to traveling long distances. Using direct current — as some areas in Canada, China and Africa do — would enable solar energy collected in sunny Albuquerque to travel to overcast Seattle with minimal loss. When the energy reaches Seattle, local power companies would convert it back into AC before distributing it to homes. Some researchers imagine such transmission lines even crossing continents. “Back in the ’70s, there was this idea of the global grid,” Hoffert says. If power line efficiency were optimized, he says, “we could ship electricity all over the world, from a place where the sun is shining to the nighttime hemisphere.”

Finally, integrating solar energy into the grid will require a major restructuring of current power generators, slowly phasing out stations that rely upon burning fossil fuels and replacing them with others that handle energy from renewable sources like solar. “We need to restructure the power system completely in terms of the types of generators we’re building,” says Solomon Abebe Asfaw, a postdoctoral fellow at theRenewable and Appropriate Energy Laboratory at the University of California, Berkeley. Though this is one of solar’s major hurdles, he believes it can be done. “I personally think, yes, this is solvable, and that solar has the capability to supply the world’s energy demand,” he says.

Ensia is a media platform that’s out to change the world. Powered by the University of Minnesota’s Institute on the Environment and cutting across disciplines, ideologies, sectors and continents, our print and online magazine and events showcase solutions to Earth’s biggest environmental challenges.

1 Comment

  • Reply May 11, 2013

    Alex Lester

    Apparently the authors forgot economics and the US not being as foolish as others in wasting money. Now solar will come to be a good source of electricity in special circumstances. I hope to see this in my lifetime, but it needs much better products that are cost effective with grid provided, and better storage as well. Perhaps in 20 years we will be there, until then solar is valuable in niche applications such as cell towers where grid power is not really avaiable, or in the military.

Leave a Reply